Each cake is meticulously crafted, filled, frosted, and adorned with precision using only the finest ingredients. We proudly use organic free-range eggs, organic sugars, unbleached King Arthur flour, and European butter. Everything is baked in small batches, without preservatives, GMOs, or hydrogenated oils.
Select your preferred cake size and flavor from our options below. For inspiration, browse our gallery of previous custom cakes.
Order Online: Fill out the simple form above with your selections
Call/Text Us: Place your order by phone at 970-214-4961
Timnath Pickup: Pick up your cake in Timnath at a pre-determined time.
Local Delivery: Local delivery can be coordinated for a small fee.
A delicate vanilla cake layered with vanilla whipped white chocolate ganache and wrapped in silky vanilla Swiss meringue buttercream.
Decadent chocolate cake stacked with whipped chocolate ganache and swirled with rich chocolate Swiss meringue buttercream.
A luxurious red velvet cake paired with fresh strawberries and a luscious cardamom cream cheese frosting.
Nutty brown butter cake with tart raspberry compote and smooth brown butter Swiss meringue buttercream.
Whimsical funfetti cake layered with funfetti cake crumble and swirled with birthday cake Swiss meringue buttercream.
Coconut cake with tangy passion fruit curd, toasted coconut flakes, and velvety coconut Swiss meringue buttercream.
Indulgent chocolate cake layered with whipped chocolate ganache, a Kirsch cherry compote, and vanilla Swiss meringue buttercream.
Rich chocolate cake with dulce de leche filling, a chocolate feuilletine crunch, and creamy dulce de leche buttercream.
Apple spiced cake filled with salted caramel and enveloped in coffee-kissed Swiss meringue buttercream.
Bright lemon cake paired with tangy lemon curd, creamy lemon Swiss meringue buttercream, and crowned with delicate meringue kisses.
Warm spiced vanilla cake with Biscoff cookie butter, a creamy white chocolate whipped ganache, and Biscoff Swiss meringue buttercream.
Chocolate cake layered with chocolate peanut butter ganache, chopped peanut butter cups, and decadent peanut butter Swiss meringue buttercream.
Vanilla cake with sweet strawberry compote, brown butter crumble filling, and light vanilla Swiss meringue buttercream.
Luxurious chocolate cake with a bourbon pecan filling and nutty brown butter Swiss meringue buttercream.
Four Inch Cake - (2-4 Servings). Starts at $80
Six Inch Cake - (12-16 Servings) Starts at $105
Eight Inch Cake - (20-24 Servings) Starts at $135
Ten Inch Cake - (30-32 Servings) Starts at $165
Small Two Tiered - 6 inch and 4 inch diameter tiers (16+ servings). Starts at $195
Classic Two Tiered - 8 inch and 6 inch diameter tiers (36+ servings). Starts at $305
Brown Butter Bakeshop
2936 Fractus Street
Be the first to know about exclusive offers and special events. Sign up today and receive $5 off your next order!