• Home
  • Menu
    • Pastries & Desserts
    • Sandwiches & Beverages
  • Custom Cakes
    • Celebration Cake Orders
    • Wedding Cake Orders
    • Cake Gallery
    • Care & Instructions
  • Events & Catering
  • About
  • Contact
  • More
    • Home
    • Menu
      • Pastries & Desserts
      • Sandwiches & Beverages
    • Custom Cakes
      • Celebration Cake Orders
      • Wedding Cake Orders
      • Cake Gallery
      • Care & Instructions
    • Events & Catering
    • About
    • Contact
  • Sign In
  • Create Account

  • My Account
  • Signed in as:

  • filler@godaddy.com


  • My Account
  • Sign out

Signed in as:

filler@godaddy.com

  • Home
  • Menu
    • Pastries & Desserts
    • Sandwiches & Beverages
  • Custom Cakes
    • Celebration Cake Orders
    • Wedding Cake Orders
    • Cake Gallery
    • Care & Instructions
  • Events & Catering
  • About
  • Contact

Account


  • My Account
  • Sign out


  • Sign In
  • My Account

Celebration Cakes

Your Celebration Cake Journey Starts Here!

Choose Your Details

Choose Your Details

Choose Your Details

Select your cake size and flavor from our options below. For inspiration, browse our cake portfolio, link below.

Cake Portfolio

Place Your Order

Choose Your Details

Choose Your Details

Order Online: Fill out the form, link below.

Order Form

Pickup or Delivery

Choose Your Details

Pickup or Delivery

Pickup: From our Sister Bay location. Local Delivery: Available for a fee.

Signature Cake Flavors

Classic Vanilla Bean

Tender vanilla sponge paired with our silky signature vanilla Swiss meringue buttercream.

Midnight Chocolate

Decadent, deep chocolate sponge layered with rich chocolate Swiss meringue buttercream. 

Sprinkle Celebration

Funfetti cake loaded with "birthday cake" crumble and festive Swiss meringue buttercream.

Passion Fruit & Coconut

Light coconut cake filled with zesty passion fruit curd and creamy coconut buttercream.

Strawberry & Cream

Vanilla sponge with house-made strawberry jam and silky vanilla Swiss meringue buttercream.

Lemon Vanilla Twist

Vanilla sponge layered with tart, scratch-made lemon curd and airy lemon buttercream.

Door County Cherry Chocolate

Rich chocolate cake filled with tart Door County cherry jam and smooth vanilla buttercream.

Raspberry Brown Butter

Deep, nutty brown butter sponge with raspberry jam and our signature brown butter buttercream.

Salted Caramel & Chocolate

Chocolate cake with house-made salted caramel, toasted pecans, and rich chocolate buttercream.

Door County Cherry Pistachio

Toasty pistachio cake paired with tart Door County cherry jam and silky pistachio buttercream.

Earl Gray Citrus

Earl Grey sponge filled with vanilla bean pastry cream and finished with citrus buttercream.

Peanut Butter Brown Butter

Nutty brown butter cake layered with airy peanut butter mousse and brown butter buttercream.

Celebration Cake Sizes & Pricing

Single-Tier Cakes

Six Inch Cake - (12-16 Servings) Starts at $115

Eight Inch Cake - (20-24 Servings) Starts at $150

Ten Inch Cake - (30-32 Servings) Starts at $185

Multi-Tier Cakes

Small Two Tiered - 6 inch and 4 inch diameter tiers (16+ servings). Starts at $205

Classic Two Tiered - 8 inch and 6 inch diameter tiers (36+ servings). Starts at $325

Large Three Tiered - 10 inch, 8 inch, and 4 inch diameter tiers (40+ servings). Starts at $415

EVERY CAKE TELLS A STORY: Browse Our Cake portfolio

Wedding Cakes
Celebration Cakes
Kids Cakes

Ready to Order?

Order Here
  • Home
  • Pastries & Desserts
  • Sandwiches & Beverages
  • Celebration Cake Orders
  • Wedding Cake Orders
  • Events & Catering
  • About
  • Contact

Brown Butter Bakeshop

10592 Country Walk Dr UNIT 19, Sister Bay, WI 54234

920-363-2560

Copyright © 2026 Brown Butter Bakeshop - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

Thurs - Sunday 8am - 2pm

Country Walk Shops, Sister Bay

Park in the Piggy Wiggly lot, next to Twisted Tree, walk to the lower level.