Your Wedding Cake Journey

Cake Consultation

Not sure where to start? Let's chat! Book a complimentary consultation call to talk through your cake design, flavors, sizing, and delivery or pickup options. We'll make sure every detail is just right before you order.

Schedule Call

Cake Tasting

The best part of the process! Select up to three of our signature flavors to sample for $45, available for pickup at our Sister Bay bakery. It's the perfect way to find your favorites before committing to your cake.

Book Cake Tasting

Cake Ordering

Ready to make it official? Complete our order form below and we'll be in touch within 1–2 business days to confirm your details and get everything in motion.

Order Form

Signature Cake Flavors

Classic Vanilla Bean

Tender vanilla sponge paired with our silky signature vanilla Swiss meringue buttercream.

Midnight Chocolate

Decadent, deep chocolate sponge layered with rich chocolate Swiss meringue buttercream.

Sprinkle Celebration

Funfetti cake loaded with "birthday cake" crumble and festive Swiss meringue buttercream.

Passion Fruit & Coconut

Light coconut cake filled with zesty passion fruit curd and creamy coconut buttercream.

Strawberry & Cream

Vanilla sponge with house-made strawberry jam and silky vanilla Swiss meringue buttercream.

Lemon Vanilla Twist

Vanilla sponge layered with tart, scratch-made lemon curd and airy lemon buttercream.

Door County Cherry Chocolate

Rich chocolate cake filled with tart Door County cherry jam and smooth vanilla buttercream.

Raspberry Brown Butter

Deep, nutty brown butter sponge with raspberry jam and our signature brown butter buttercream.

Salted Caramel & Chocolate

Chocolate cake with house-made salted caramel, toasted pecans, and rich chocolate buttercream.

Door County Cherry Pistachio

Toasty pistachio cake paired with tart Door County cherry jam and silky pistachio buttercream.

Earl Gray Citrus

Earl Grey sponge filled with vanilla bean pastry cream and finished with citrus buttercream.

Peanut Butter Brown Butter

Nutty brown butter cake layered with airy peanut butter mousse and brown butter buttercream.

Decorated Sheet Cakes

Need to serve a bigger crowd? Wedding sheet cakes are a beautiful and practical way to extend your dessert table — sheet-style layers of your chosen wedding flavors, filled and frosted with Swiss meringue buttercream and ready to slice.

$200 per sheet cake, Serves 24-30 people

Sheet cakes are a perfect complement to a smaller tiered cake, or a stunning standalone display for larger guest counts.

Dessert Bites

Our Dessert Bites are two-bite portions of Brown Butter's signature baked goods, made to mix, match, and graze.

$4 each · Minimum order of 24

Choose from: Signature Cake · Miso Caramel Pecan Bar · Frosted Brownie · Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie

Signature cakes are available in all twelve flavors.

A Few Things to Know

Décor & Display Most decorative elements are included in your cake design. If you'd like fresh florals, a cake topper, ribbon, or decorative figures, those are yours to provide. You'll also want to have a cake stand or platter ready — sturdy and weight-bearing for tiered cakes.

Delivery Delivery and setup starts at $95 depending on your venue location and setup needs. Your cake should stay refrigerated until 1–2 hours before serving.

Ready to make it official?

Booking & Payment A signed contract and 50% non-refundable deposit reserve your date. Final payment is due two weeks before your event. Payments are non-refundable and non-transferable.