• Home
  • Custom Cakes
    • Celebration Cake Orders
    • Wedding Cake Orders
    • Cake Gallery
    • Care & Instructions
  • Pastry & Dessert
  • Order
  • About
  • Contact
  • More
    • Home
    • Custom Cakes
      • Celebration Cake Orders
      • Wedding Cake Orders
      • Cake Gallery
      • Care & Instructions
    • Pastry & Dessert
    • Order
    • About
    • Contact
  • Home
  • Custom Cakes
    • Celebration Cake Orders
    • Wedding Cake Orders
    • Cake Gallery
    • Care & Instructions
  • Pastry & Dessert
  • Order
  • About
  • Contact

Pastry & Dessert

What We Bake

Everything at Brown Butter Bakeshop is made from scratch, in small batches, each week. Our pastry case rotates with the seasons. What we're baking this week may not be what we baked last week, and that's exactly how we like it.

Rather than a fixed menu, think of this as a look at the kinds of things you might find in the case when you walk through the door. For what's actually available this week, follow us on Instagram or Facebook.

Walk-ins welcome Thursday–Sunday, 8am–2pm. We do not take pre-orders, everything is first-come, first-serve.

Brioche Pastries

Brioche Pastries

Brioche Pastries

Hand-shaped, slow-fermented, and rotated weekly. Spirals, filled buns, and brioche donuts dressed with seasonal fruits, house-made creams, and glazes — savory options too. From $8

Morning Cakes

Brioche Pastries

Brioche Pastries

Individual brown butter coffee cakes with seasonal fillings. Tender crumb, crunchy streusel, not-too-sweet. From $8

Danish Pastries

Brioche Pastries

Danish Pastries

Laminated dough, folded and layered by hand, filled with seasonal fruits, creams, and house-made preserves. Flaky, buttery, and rotated with whatever's at peak. From $9

Bars & Brownies

Bars & Brownies

Danish Pastries

Generous slabs with layered flavor. Our miso caramel pecan oat bar is a bakeshop staple. The brownie is made without gluten, finished with salted dulce de leche. From $7

Cake Slices

Bars & Brownies

Cake Slices

Slab-style slices of our signature cakes, filled and frosted with Swiss meringue buttercream. A great way to try a flavor before committing to a full custom order. From $8

Cookies

Bars & Brownies

Cake Slices

Brown butter chocolate chunk. Frosted birthday cake. Thick, soft-centered, and rotated with whatever the season calls for. From $5

Dessert Bites: Event & Catering Orders


Order Form

Whether you're planning a wedding dessert table, a birthday party spread, or a catered event, our Dessert Bites are built for it. Each one is a two-bite portion of Brown Butter's scratch-made baked goods — the same quality and flavor you'd find in the case, scaled for a crowd and mixed to your taste.

What's Included

Signature Cakes — Available in all twelve signature flavors, filled and frosted with Swiss meringue buttercream. Choose one or mix several.

Miso Caramel Pecan Bars — Our miso caramel pecan oat bar in a two-bite format. Sweet, salty, and a little addictive.

Frosted Brownies — Fudgy, gluten-free brownie finished with a swirl of dark chocolate ganache. 

Brown Butter Chocolate Cookies — Crisp edges, soft center, brown butter depth. The one people always come back for.

How it Works

Mix and match up to four varieties per order. We'll arrange them beautifully for pickup, or discuss display options if you're adding delivery.


$4 each · Minimum order of 24


Dessert Bites are available by pre-order only and require advance notice. Use the order form below or reach out to discuss larger event quantities.

Order Form

Something to Sip

Every drink is made to order with our housemade syrups — Brown Butter, Vanilla, Cinnamon, and Miso Caramel. Signature lattes, matcha, chai, refreshers, smoothies, and teas. The kind of coffee shop you'd drive out of your way for, right in the heart of Sister Bay.

Our weekly pastry lineup is posted on Instagram & Facebook. Follow along @Brown.Butter.Bakeshop

Instagram
  • Home
  • Celebration Cake Orders
  • Wedding Cake Orders
  • Pastry & Dessert
  • Order
  • About
  • Contact

Brown Butter Bakeshop

10592 Country Walk Dr UNIT 19, Sister Bay, WI 54234

920-363-2560

Copyright © 2026 Brown Butter Bakeshop - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

Thurs - Monday 8am - 2pm

Country Walk Shops, Sister Bay

Park in the Piggy Wiggly lot, next to Twisted Tree, walk to the lower level.