• Home
  • Custom Cakes
    • Celebration Cake Orders
    • Wedding Cake Orders
    • Signature Cake Flavors
    • Cake Gallery
    • Care & Instructions
  • Pastry & Dessert
  • Order
  • About
  • Contact
  • More
    • Home
    • Custom Cakes
      • Celebration Cake Orders
      • Wedding Cake Orders
      • Signature Cake Flavors
      • Cake Gallery
      • Care & Instructions
    • Pastry & Dessert
    • Order
    • About
    • Contact
  • Home
  • Custom Cakes
    • Celebration Cake Orders
    • Wedding Cake Orders
    • Signature Cake Flavors
    • Cake Gallery
    • Care & Instructions
  • Pastry & Dessert
  • Order
  • About
  • Contact

Pastry & Dessert Menu

Scratch-Made Pastry

In rotation, please check @Brown.Butter.Bakeshop or visit the Sister Bay bakery for current availability.

Maple Bacon Gouda Brioche

$8

Brioche spiral with maple-glazed black pepper bacon, everything bagel seasoning, dijon mustard and gouda.

Cinnamon Walnut Brioche

$7

Brioche spiraled with cinnamon and house-made walnut paste then topped with walnut streusel. 

Brown Butter Almond Brioche

$7

Brioche swirled with house-made brown butter almond cream topped with orange almond glaze and almond slivers. 

Raspberry Pistachio Coffee Cake

$6

Brown butter coffee cake baked with pistachio cream cheese filling, fresh raspberries then topped pistachios.

Berry Cheesecake Brioche

$7

Brioche baked with brown butter vanilla cheesecake filling, seasonal berries and crunchy streusel. 

Strawberries & Cream Brioche

$7

Brioche buns baked with vanilla pastry cream, strawberry compote then topped with fresh strawberries and streusel. 

Seasonal Filled Brioche "Donuts"

$7

Brioche buns filled with seasonal pastry cream and rolled in crunchy streusel. 

Earl Grey Chocolate Brioche

$7

Brioche buns infused with Earl Grey and dark chocolate chunks, then piped with chocolate pastry cream. 

Blueberry Lemon Brioche

$7

Brioche buns baked with lemon curd, blueberry compote then topped with fresh blueberries and pearl sugar. 

Mouth-Watering Desserts

In rotation, please check @Brown.Butter.Bakeshop or visit the Sister Bay bakery for current availability.

Mini Cake

$8

4" cake filled and frosted, highlighting our signature cake flavors. Bigger than a cupcake, meant to share....or not! 

Miso Caramel Pecan Oat Bar

$5

Oat bar baked with house-made miso caramel and toasted pecans.

S'Mores Brioche

$8

Brioche buns glazed with chocolate, topped with a house-made vanilla marshmallow and graham cracker flakes.  

Dulce de Leche Brownie (GF)

$5

Chocolate brownie crafted without gluten, topped with salted Dulce de Leche.

Frosted Un-Birthday Cake Cookie

$4

Super-soft birthday cake cookie with vanilla cream cheese frosting and sprinkles. 

Brown Butter Chocolate Chunk Cookie

$4

Brown butter cookies with chunks of dark chocolate and topped with flaked salt.

Looking to Pre-Order?

Order Form
  • Home
  • Celebration Cake Orders
  • Wedding Cake Orders
  • Pastry & Dessert
  • Order
  • About
  • Contact

Brown Butter Bakeshop

10592 Country Walk Dr UNIT 19, Sister Bay, WI 54234

Copyright © 2026 Brown Butter Bakeshop - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

Reopening May 2026!

in Sister Bay, WI. Stay tuned for more details!